Court of Appeal Legal Diary, 2018-10-01

• Judgment Date: 01 October 2018
• Issuer: Court of Appeal

NOTICE

The attention of practitioners is drawn to the provisions of Statutory Practice Direction CA06 as to the requirements in relation to submissions, books of appeal and books of authorities in civil appeals.

Directions Lists and Motions List
See Notice in the Notices section of this website as to the revised arrangements for these Lists.
The attention of practitioners is drawn to the provisions of Order 86 Rule 12 (5) (dealing with Interlocutory applications) and Order 86A Rule 16 (1) (directions hearings) as to the requirement for the lodgement in the court office of the relevant booklets.

Failure to comply with these provisions may result in an appeal being struck out and/or costs orders being made against the party in default or their solicitors.



In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Irvine
Mr Justice Hogan
Mr Justice Hedigan
At 10.30 o'clock
For hearing
2014 176 Smith -v- Meade & ors (68/10 SC)

Mr Justice Peart
Ms Justice Irvine
Mr Justice Hogan
At 2 o'clock
For mention
2016 420 G -v- P

Mr Justice Hogan
Ms Justice Whelan
Mr Justice McGovern
At 2 o'clock
For Judgment
2017 293 Sweetman -v- Coillte Teoranta

Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice Hogan
Ms Justice Whelan
At 2 o'clock
For Costs & Form of Order
2016 205 Knockacummer Wind Farm Ltd -v- Cremins & Ors

Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice Hogan
Ms Justice Whelan
At 2 o'clock
For hearing
2017 362 Dolmen Estates Ltd & ors -v- Carlow County Council (1h)


Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice Hogan
Ms Justice Baker
At 3 o'clock
For Costs & Form of Order
2016 267 Rozmyslowicz -v- Minister for Justice and Equality & ors

In Court 22, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice Hedigan
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 2 o'clock
For Judgment
2018 30 R -v DPP

For hearing
Bail appeal
2018 290 DPP -v- Byrne



Tuesday the 2nd October 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice Hogan
Ms Justice Whelan
At 10 o'clock
For Costs
2018 2 In the matter of Peter Clohessy (Deceased)

Mr Justice Peart
Ms Justice Irvine
Mr Justice Hogan
At 10.15 o'clock
For Costs (motions)
2016 526 Fennell -v- Ward & Anor (+ appeal for mention)
2017 46 Fennell -v- Ward & Anor (+ appeal for mention)

Ms Justice Irvine
Ms Justice Whelan
Ms Justice Baker
At 10.30 o'clock
For Hearing
2017 394 McKelvey -v- Irish Rail (1d)

Ms Justice Irvine
Mr Justice Hogan
Ms Justice Baker
At 2 o'clock
For Judgment
2018 46 Dowling & Ors -v- The Minister for Finance & Ors
2018 47 Dowling & Ors -v- The Minister for Finance & Ors

For Mention
2015 87 Dowling & ors -v- Minister for Finance
2015 209 Dowling & ors -v- Permanent TSB Group Holdings plc & ors
Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice Hogan
Ms Justice Baker
At 2 o'clock
For Judgment
2016 394 McDonough -v- O'Shea & Ors
2017 14 Diesel SpA -v- The Controller of Patents, Designs and Trademarks & Anor
2017 18 Diesel SpA -v- The Controller of Patents, Designs and Trademarks & Anor

In Court 22, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice Hedigan
At 10 o'clock
For Judgment
2017 107 S.A.S -v The Minister for Justice & Equality
2017 108 A.A.S -v- The Minister for Justice & Equality

At 10.30 o'clock
For Hearing
2018 377 M (a minor) -v- The Child and Family Agency

Wednesday the 3rd October 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Finlay Geoghegan
Mr Justice Hogan
Mr Justice Edwards
At 9.45 o'clock
For Costs
2016 104 DPP -v- Independent News and Media plc & Ors

Ms Justice Finlay Geoghegan
Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice Hogan
At 10 o'clock
For Costs
2016 196 Flynn & Anor -v- Breccia
2016 197 Sheehan -v- Breccia & Ors

Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice Hogan
Ms Justice Whelan
At 10.15 o'clock
For Costs
2014 1139 McCarthy -v- ISS Ireland Ltd & anor (21/14 SC)

Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice McGovern
Ms Justice Baker
At 10.30 o'clock
For Hearing
2014 779 Monahan -v- Dunnes Stores & anor (1d)

The President
Mr Justice Hogan
Ms Justice Whelan
At 2 o'clock
For Costs
2016 573 Dillon -v- Board of Management of Catholic University School

Ms Justice Irvine
Mr Justice Hogan
Ms Justice Baker
At 2 o'clock
For Costs
2018 46 Dowling & Ors -v- The Minister for Finance & Ors
2018 47 Dowling & Ors -v- The Minister for Finance & Ors

For Mention
2015 87 Dowling & ors -v- Minister for Finance
2015 209 Dowling & ors -v- Permanent TSB Group Holdings plc & ors

In Court 2, Court of Appeal Building
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Whelan
At 1.50 o'clock
For Judgment
2018 329 G -v- B

Thursday the 4th October 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Irvine
At 9.30 o'clock
For mention (re. re-entry of appeals)
2014 800 Egan -v- Commissioner of an Garda Siochana & ors
2014 810 Egan -v- Commissioner of an Garda Siochana & ors
2015 293 White -v- Office of Public Works & ors
2015 294 White -v- Office of Public Works & ors

Article 64 - Callover List
This List comprises appeals adjourned from a Callover on the 24th July 2018 when the Court directed that in each of the cases listed below the submissions of the respondent be filed and served by the 12th of September 2018 and that the appeal booklets be lodged in the court office by the 28th of September 2018

1. 2014 530 Kelly -v- Dublin City Council & Ors (308/12 SC)
2. 2014 890 Naughton -v- O'Callaghan (284/13 SC)
3. 2014 952 Harrahill -v- Prendergast (377/13 SC)
4. 2014 1168 S.D. (a minor) & anor -v- Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade (95/14 SC)
5. 2014 1208 A.M. (a minor) & anor -v- Minister for Foreign Affairs & Trade (96/14 SC)
6. 2014 1209 Horan & anor -v- Circuit Court Judge McCabe (131/14 SC)
7. 2014 1234 Kenny & ors -v- Minister for Justice Equality & Law Reform & ors (212/14 SC)
8. 2014 1242 Kenny & ors -v- Minister for Justice Equality & Law Reform & ors (222/14 SC)
9. 2014 1247 Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland -v- Coughlan (242/14 SC)
10. 2014 1284 Watt -v- Moylan (285/14 SC)
11. 2014 1319 Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank -v- Barrett & anor (350/14 SC)
12. 2014 1321 Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank -v- Barrett & anor (351/14 SC)
13. 2014 415 O'Shea & Anor -v- Butler & Ors (138/12 SC)
14. 2014 759 O'Shea -v- Butler & Anor (74/13 SC)
15. 2014 760 O'Shea -v- Butler & Anor (73/13 SC)
16. 2014 533 A -v- The Minister for Justice & Equality (319/12 SC)
17. 2014 541 A -v- The Minister for Justice & Equality (320/12 SC)
18. 2014 608 Murphy -v- Callinan, Ireland, Attorney General & Garda Commissioner (435/12 SC)
19. 2014 650 Jackie Greene Construction Ltd -v- Irish Nationwide Bld. Soc. (514/12 SC)
20. 2014 726 Looney -v- Punch Holdings (formerly Punch & Co Ltd & Ors (20/13 SC)
21. 2014 983 Meagher & anor -v- Doherty (417/13 SC)
22. 2014 987 Allied Irish Banks plc -v- Fardy & anor (424/13 SC)
23. 2014 1098 Burns & McAteer -v- Quinn & Ors (178/14SC)
24. 2014 1356 Allied Irish Banks plc -v- O'Regan (386/14 SC)
25. 2014 564 Lombard Ireland Ltd -v- Schoenmakers (362/12 SC)
26. 2014 382 O'Hara -v- Eire Bus Ltd & Anor (74/12 SC)
27. 2014 609 Toher t/a Vincent Toher & Co. -v- Fitzgerald (434/12 SC)
28. 2014 610 Toher t/a Vincent Toher & Co. -v- Fitzgerald (433/12 SC)
29. 2014 631 Toher t/a Vincent Toher & Co. -v- Fitzgerald (479/12 SC)
30. 2014 687 ACC Bank plc -v- Feeley & Anor (563/12 SC)
31. 2014 690 ACC Bank plc -v- Feeley (564/12 SC)
32. 2014 694 K -v- Judge Heneghan & Ors (574/12 SC)
33. 2014 716 DeCataldo -v- Petrogas Group Ltd & Ors (10/13 SC)
34. 2014 717 O'Gara -v- Murray (8/13 SC)
35. 2014 736 Hall -v- The Minister for Finance & Ors (32/13 SC)
36. 2014 764 McGuckian Oils Ltd -v- O'Regan (82/13 SC)
37. 2014 1061 Allied Irish Banks plc -v- Doherty (512/13 SC)
38. 2014 1135 Rayan Restaurant Ltd & Ors -v- Flynn (38/14 SC)
39. 2014 1141 Bank of Ireland -v- Higgins (126/14SC)
40. 2014 1296 Minister for Health -v- Information Commissioner & ors (309/14 SC)
41. 2014 927 Ulster Bank Ireland Ltd -v- Collins (350/13 SC)
42. 2014 715 Wallace -v- Heffernan & Anor (9/13 SC)
43. 2014 652 O'Connell -v CFS Developments Ltd (513/12 SC)
44. 2014 774 F -v- M (92/13 SC)
45. 2014 992 F -v- M (429/13 SC)
46. 2014 1212 The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland -v- Lynch & Anor (139/14 SC)

Ms Justice Irvine
Mr Justice Hogan
Ms Justice Whelan
At 1 o'clock
For Costs
2017 113 Tyrrell -v- Wright

2017 559 Coyle -v- Gray
2017 560 Coyle -v- Gray
2017 562 Gray -v- Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank & Ors

In Court 2, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice MacMenamin
Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice Hedigan
At 10 o'clock
For costs
2016 374 Law Society -v- O'Sullivan

Mr Justice Peart
Ms Justice Whelan
Mr Justice McGovern
At 10.30 o'clock
For Mention (re. costs)
2018 373 In the matter of Openhydro Group Limited (In Provisional Liquidation)

In Court 22, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice Hedigan
At 10.15 o'clock
For mention
2016 551 O'Mahoney -v- District Judge Hughes & Anor
2016 555 O'Mahoney -v- District Judge Hughes & Anor

The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
For hearing
2017 581 DPP -v- James Kelly & ors
2017 357 Murtagh -v- Judge Kevin Kilrane & ors

Friday the 5th October 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Irvine
At 10 o'clock
Callover of cases for week beginning 22nd October
2016 534 Thompson & anor -v-Grant Thornton Ire & ors
2017 35 Lamba -v- FBD Insurance Holdings plc
2017 298 Sherlock -v- Ennis Town Council
2015 652 M -v- M
2017 328 Cash -v- Wexford County Council
2017 263 Gladney -v- Daly
2017 254 T.E. -v- Minister for Justice & Equality
2018 252 Hickey -v- KBC Bank Ireland plc
_____________________________
For mention
2016 452 CAB v Murphy (FH 11th Oct - no papers)
________________________________
At 10.30 o'clock
For mention
2016 475 Murphy (Liquidator) -v- Kelly & anor (+ 2016 476 & 2016 542)
2014 720 Davidson -v- Corrigan & anor
2016 90 Lynn -v- O'Hara & anor (+ motion)
2016 188 Lynn -v- O'Hara & anor (+ motion)

Directions List
Expedited appeals
1. 2017 471 O'Rourke -v- O'Rourke & Ors
2. 2017 322 O'Rourke -v- O'Rourke & ors
3. 2017 323 O'Rourke -v- O'Rourke & ors
4. 2018 247 Dolan...