Court of Appeal Legal Diary, 2018-11-07

• Judgment Date: 07 November 2018
• Issuer: Court of Appeal

NOTICE

The attention of practitioners is drawn to the provisions of Statutory Practice Direction CA06 as to the requirements in relation to submissions, books of appeal and books of authorities in civil appeals.

Directions Lists and Motions List
See Notice in the Notices section of this website as to the revised arrangements for these Lists.
The attention of practitioners is drawn to the provisions of Order 86 Rule 12 (5) (dealing with Interlocutory applications) and Order 86A Rule 16 (1) (directions hearings) as to the requirement for the lodgement in the court office of the relevant booklets.

Failure to comply with these provisions may result in an appeal being struck out and/or costs orders being made against the party in default or their solicitors.


Wednesday the 7th November 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice McGovern
Ms Justice Costello
At 2 o'clock
For hearing
2015 376 AIB Mortgage Bank -v- O'Doherty (2h)




Thursday the 8th November 2018
[Article 64 List to Fix Dates is deferred - see Notice]
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice Peart
Ms Justice Whelan
Mr Justice McGovern
At 10.30 o'clock
For hearing
2016 472 C -v- Clinical Director Central Mental Hospital & anor (1d)

In Court 22, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr. Justice Edwards
Mr. Justice McCarthy
Ms. Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o'clock
2018 36 Collins (on bail) v DPP

Friday the 9th November 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Irvine
At 10 o'clock
Callover of cases for hearing during week beginning 26th November 2018
2016 442 Kildare Co Council -v- Reid
2018 138 K.N. & ors -v- Minister for Justice and Equality
2018 141 M.A.M. -v- Minister for Justice and Equality
2017 98 Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank -v- Brooks
2017 69 Permanent TSB plc -v- Burns & anor
2017 71 F.P. -v- Information Commissioner
2017 346 Joyce -v- Galway Clinic Doughiska Ltd
____________________________
For mention
2014 838 Allied Irish Bank plc -v- Aqua Fresh Fish Ltd (207/13 SC)
2017 591 V & Ors -v- The Refugee Appeals Tribunal & Ors
2017 266 Cantrell -v- Allied Irish Banks plc & ors
2017 268 Cantrell -v- Allied Irish Banks plc & ors
2017 271 Cantrell -v- Allied Irish Banks plc & ors
2017 273 Cantrell -v- Allied Irish Banks plc & ors


At 10.30 o'clock
For mention
2017 486 S -v- T
2017 175 Shaughnessy -v- Nohilly & anor

Directions List
Expedited Appeals
1. 2018 274 McAteer & Ors -v- Fried & Ors
2. 2018 278 Murphy -v- Connolly & Ors
3. 2018 76 McGillivary & Anor -v- Bradshaw & Anor
4. 2018 390 Beakey -v- Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank
5. 2018 287 Allied Irish Bank plc -v- McCarthy & Anor
6. 2018 396 AIB Mortgage Bank -v- Gunning & Anor (no book lodged)
7. 2018 399 The Governor and Company of The Bank of Ireland & Anor -v- Lyons & Ors
8. 2018 400 Seery -v- Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank (no book lodged)
9. 2018 22 ACC Loan Management DAC -v- McCool
10. 2018 404 Daoud -v- Kelly & Ors
11. 2018 165 Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland -v- Tomkin
12. 2018 333 Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) Ltd t/a Pepper Asset Servicing -v- Hanley & Anor
13. 2018 344 Promotoria (Arrow Ltd) -v- Dineen
14. 2018 346 Ennis Property Finance -v- Carney (no book lodged)
15. 2018 299 O'Neill -v- O'Connor

At 11 o'clock
Ordinary appeals
16. 2018 378 By Order KBC Bank Ireland plc -v- Beades (no book lodged)
17. 2018 393 Chakari -v- The Criminal Injuries Tribunal & Ors
18. 2018 347 Coonan -v- Hayes Solicitors (formerly Hayes & Sons)
19. 2018 368 McAndrew -v- Launceston Property Finance DAC & Anor
20. 2018 326 Gbolaru -v- Olowoski & Anor

At 11.30 o'clock
Motion List
21. 2018 288 A.K. -v- The Minister for Justice & Equality
22. 2018 274 McAteer & Ors -v- Fried & Ors
23. 2014 579 McEnery -v- Sheahan
24. 2014 628 Allied Irish Banks Plc -v- Smith
25. 2018 396 AIB Mortgage Bank -v- Gunning & Anor
26. 2018 282 Allied Irish Banks plc -v- Kennedy & Anor
27. 2018 399 The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland -v- Lyons & Ors
28. 2018 232 Kossecki -v- Masterlink Overnight & Anor
29. 2018 76 McGillivary & Anor -v- Bradshaw & Anor

At 2.15 o'clock
Motion (+ appeal for directions)
2018 401 Morrin & anor -v- Tanager Ltd & ors

In Court 2, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice McGovern
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
For hearing
2017 177 Allied Irish Banks plc & ors -v- Gibney & anor
2017 612 Allied Irish Banks plc & ors -v- Gibney & anor (1d for both)

Monday the 12th November 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Irvine
Ms Justice Whelan
Ms Justice Baker
At 10 o'clock
For costs
2017 394 McKelvey -v- Iarnrod Eireann

At 10.30 o'clock
Adjourned motion
2018 92 O'Sullivan -v- An Bord Pleanala (ex parte appeal)

Motion List (no motions yet listed)

At 11 o'clock (after Motion List)
For hearing
2017 437 In the matter of Private Banking Ltd (1h)

At 2 o'clock
For hearing
2017 441 Byrne -v- Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal & anor (2h)

In Court 22, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10 o'clock
List to Fix Dates - Article 64 appeals
This List comprises appeals adjourned from a Callover on the 4th May 2018 when the Court gave directions as to submissions
1. 2014 90 Tracey v District Judge McCarthy (DPP Notice Party) (SC290/06)
2. 2014 113 Tracey v Same (SC24/08)
3. 2014 349 DPP v District Judge McGrath & ors (SC22/12)
4. 2014 369 Same v Same (cross-appeal to above appeal) (SC45/12)
5. 2014 821 Kershaw v Judge Griffin & anor (SC180/13)
6. 2014 900 Grimes v Judge O'Donnabhain (SC309/13)
7. 2014 948 Gunar v Judge O'Donnabhain & DPP (SC371/13)
8. 2014 1089 Walshe v Judge Keys & ors (including DPP) (SC160/14)
9. 2014 1137 Balauta v His Honour Judge Keenan Johnston & DPP (SC29/14)

Tuesday the 13th November 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice McGovern
Ms Justice Baker
At 10.30 o'clock
Motion
2017 167 Allied Irish Banks plc -v- Twohig & ors (30 minutes)

Mr Justice Peart
Ms Justice Whelan
Ms Justice Baker
At 2 o'clock
For hearing
2016 280 Camiveo -v- Dunnes Stores (2h)

Wednesday the 14th November 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Irvine
At 10 o'clock
Callover of cases for hearing during week beginning 3rd December 2018
2018 233 Da Silva/Miranda & ors -v- Rosas Constructores & ors
2018 234 Da Silva/Miranda & ors -v- Rosas Constructores & ors
2018 235 Da Silva/Miranda & ors -v- Rosas Constructores & ors
2017 337 Martin -v- Minister for Social Protection
2017 369 AIB plc -v- Sheedy
2017 74 M.C. -v- Legal Aid Board & ors
2017 17 & 22 Hanrahan -v- Gladney & Attorney General
2017 171 Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank -v- Gillooly
2016 524 Boland -v- Reardens of Washington Street Ltd
2017 235 McMahon & anor -v- Mars Capital No. 2 Limited
2014 659 Boyle & anor -v- Boyle & anor
2017 338 Matute -v- Medtronic Ireland Ltd & ors
2017 209 Start Mortgages DAC -v- Keating & anor

Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McGovern
At 10.30 o'clock
For hearing
2016 169 Gladney -v- Ryan (2h) (peremptory)

At 2 o'clock
For hearing
2017 211 Chatabbou & anor -v- Ireland & ors (2h)

Thursday the 15th November 2018
[Article 64 List to Fix Dates is deferred - see Notice]
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms. Justice Irvine
At 10 o'clock
For mention (Art 64 appeals)
2014 1284 Watt v Moylan (SC285/14) (peremptory against the defendant/respondent)
2014 609 Toher trading as Vincent Toher & Co. v Fitzgerald (SC434/12)
2014 610 Same v Same (SC433/12)
2014 631 Same v Same (SC479/12)

Ms. Justice Irvine
Ms Justice Whelan
Ms Justice Baker
At 10.30 o'clock
For hearing
2017 109 Tyrrell -v- Wright & anor (1h)

At 12 o'clock
For hearing (motion)
2017 65 RHS Energy Ltd -v- ES Energy Saving Systems Ltd & ors (1h)

Mr Justice Peart
Ms Justice Irvine
Mr Justice McGovern
at 2 o'clock
For hearing
2017 189 Woods -v- Ulster Bank Ireland Ltd & ors
2017 190 Woods -v- Ulster Bank Ireland Ltd & ors (1- 2 h for both)

In Court 22, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr. Justice Edwards
Mr. Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
For hearing
2016 518 Smyth -v- DPP & ors
2018 122 Kendall -v- Minister for Justice & Equality
2017 543 White (on bail) -v- Governor of Mountjoy Prison

Friday the 23rd November 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Irvine
At 10 o'clock
Callover of cases for hearing during week beginning 10th December 2018
2017 415 Smith -v- ACC Loan Mgt Ltd & anor
2017 374 AIB plc -v- O'Reilly
2015 182, 183 Kinsella -v- Kenmare Resources plc & anor
2016 378 Galway Free Range Eggs Ltd -v- O'Brien
2017 350 Lagan Bitumen Ltd -v- Tullagower Quarries Ltd
2017 321 Mannion -v- Legal Aid Board & ors

Monday the 26th November 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice Peart
Ms Justice Irvine
Ms Justice Whelan
At 11 o'clock
Motion List
1. 2018 269 Criminal Assets Bureau -v- Connors (short appeal for hearing - 30 minutes)
2. 2018 306 L -v- The Refugee Tribunal

At 2 o'clock
For hearing
2016 442 Kildare County Council -v- Reid (2h)

Tuesday the 27th November 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice McGovern
Ms Justice Baker
Ms Justice Costello
At 10.30 o'clock
For hearing
2018 138 K.N. & Ors -v- The Minister for Justice & Equality
2018 141 M.A.M. -v- The Minister for Justice & Equality (1d)

Wednesday the 28th November 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Irvine
Ms Justice Whelan
Ms Justice Baker
At 10.30 o'clock
For hearing
2017 98 Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank -v- Brooks (1h)

At 2 o'clock
For Hearing
2017 69 Permanent TSB plc -v- Burns & anor (2h)

Thursday the 29th November 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice Peart
Mr Justice McGovern
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o'clock
For Hearing
2017 71 F.P. -v- Information Commissioner (1d)

In Court 22, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr. Justice McCarthy
Ms. Justice Baker
At 10 o'clock
For hearing
2018 265 Sharma v DPP
2018 266 Sharma v DPP
2014 519 Sharma v Judge Fullam (SC292/12)

Friday the 30th November 2018
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice...