Director of Public Prosecutions v Dunbar
| Jurisdiction | Ireland |
| Court | Court of Appeal (Ireland) |
| Judge | Mr. Justice Edwards |
| Judgment Date | 30 January 2024 |
| Neutral Citation | [2024] IECA 85 |
| Docket Number | Appeal No: 214/2020 |
[2024] IECA 85
Birmingham P.
Edwards J.
Kennedy J.
Appeal No: 214/2020
THE COURT OF APPEAL
JUDGMENT of the Court delivered by Mr. Justice Edwards on the 30 th of January 2024.
. This judgment is concerned with the appellant's appeal against his conviction by a jury for murder in the Central Criminal Court on the 2 nd of November 2020.
. The appellant has filed a Notice of Appeal in which he lists sixteen grounds of appeal. However, counsel for the appellant helpfully grouped these into five topic headings for the purposes of making submissions and for the oral hearing. We intend to structure this judgment by adopting the five topic headings proposed by the appellant and addressing the issues raised under their appropriate headings. The five topic headings were:
I. The application for the discharge of the jury;
II. Diminished responsibility;
III. Refusal to exclude part memos of interview;
IV. Admissibility of CCTV evidence;
V. The witness “AB” and associated rulings.
. The evidence adduced before the jury established that the appellant and a Mr. Adam Muldoon (i.e., “the deceased”) were socialising with others in the appellant's home area from approximately 10:00pm on the 22 nd of June 2018. The appellant had been taking alcohol and drugs. At approximately 11:48pm the appellant and the deceased travelled the short distance together, and alone, to Butler's Park in Tallaght. While they were in the park the deceased was stabbed repeatedly with a knife. Evidence adduced at trial from the State Pathologist, a Dr Margaret Bolster, was to the effect that 183 stab wounds to the body of the deceased were observed at post-mortem examination. The most serious wounds were those that punctured the lungs and liver and severed the carotid artery and jugular veins, all of which would have been fatal. Further, there were numerous defensive wounds on the hands of the deceased.
. The prosecution's case was that the stabbing was perpetrated by the appellant, and that it was murder.
. The appellant was to be seen on CCTV, harvested in the course of the subsequent investigation into the deceased's killing, returning from the park alone at approximately 00:13am on the 23 rd of June 2018.
. Shortly after the killing, the appellant went to the house of a friend, “AB”, and informed AB that he had stabbed the deceased a number of times and had killed him. Later, the appellant and AB went to a large pond where the appellant disposed of a knife.
. Further CCTV footage recorded on the 23 rd of June 2018, and harvested in the course of the Garda investigation, showed the appellant interacting with other people outside of his home during the daytime. Later, CCTV showed the appellant and AB travelling and moving consistently with the case made by the prosecution in regard to the disposal of the knife.
. Later on the same day, the appellant made a witness statement in which he made no admissions and lied about his movements on the previous night.
. Later that evening, the appellant went to a Garda station and made admissions during a voluntary cautioned statement in the presence of his grandmother, but without a solicitor and without having legal advice. In this statement, he accepted that he brought the deceased to Butler's Park on his own and that he must have stabbed him and killed him. However, he asserted that he did not actually remember stabbing the deceased. He said that he was hearing voices telling him to do things such as killing. He also referred to taking drugs.
. Having been arrested and detained, he was further interviewed in the presence of his solicitor. He made similar admissions in the course of this interview.
. There were four main strands on which the prosecution based their case. First, they relied on the admissions of the appellant to gardaí. Secondly, they relied on CCTV evidence which they contended supported the prosecution's case and tended to undermine the defendant's assertion (subsequently advanced) that the defences of diminished responsibility and/or intoxication were engaged. Thirdly, they relied upon admissions said to have been made to the appellant's friend AB in the immediate aftermath of the killing and evidence concerning the disposal of the knife. Fourthly, and finally, they relied upon DNA evidence confirming the presence of the deceased's blood on the appellant's clothes.
. At the commencement of the trial, as is usual, prosecuting counsel made an opening speech to the jury. Following that speech, defence counsel applied to the trial judge for a discharge of the jury on the basis that the speech had referenced two matters which it was contended had the potential to prejudice the jury against the accused.
. The first matter complained of was the following:
“[…] the defence may choose to test the evidence offered by the prosecution, by way of cross-examination and also, as Judge McDermott, who is the trial judge, as Judge McDermott has adverted to, there can — and this happens in every criminal trial — there can be legal issues in relation to evidential matters which have to be determined by the judge in the absence of the jury. And the defence are perfectly entitled to raise legal challenges over and above testing the evidence by way of cross-examination. So it's not the case that the defence are trying to do something that's slick or, you know, not permissible; it is entirely proper and appropriate for the defence to challenge the evidence offered by the prosecution, not just by cross-examination, but also by legal challenge. And, as Judge McDermott has said, if that happens, you are asked to withdraw to your jury room. There's nothing sinister about that. There's no reason to wonder about that because in the same way, ladies and gentlemen, when you retire to consider your verdict at the end of this trial you do so in private. You don't have the judge presiding over you. You don't have counsel and solicitor there. You do so in private.”
. It was submitted to the trial judge by defence counsel that the prosecution had strayed from the normal convention of simply stating to the jury that they would be excluded from court when legal issues were being considered. It was considered objectionable that it had been explicitly conveyed to the jury that on such occasions the defence would be challenging evidence on legal grounds, i.e., seeking to prevent the jury from hearing evidence that the prosecution were seeking to adduce. It was submitted that as the jury might be potentially prejudiced in their view of the accused arising from prosecuting counsel's remarks, the jury should be discharged.
. Prosecuting counsel responded to this by rejecting the defence criticism and emphasising that she had also told the jury (a) that there was no obligation on the part of the defence to prove anything, and (b) that the defence, if they chose to do so, could stay silent throughout the trial, but that what was equally available to the defence was an ability to challenge material by way of cross examination and also by way of legal challenge. This was, she submitted, a correct statement of the legal position.
. Having observed that, in his view, the question of legal challenges was one that could have been left alone in the opening statement, the trial judge went on to rule as follows with respect to the request that the jury should be discharged on account of what had been said in that context:
“ But, nevertheless, it's a matter that was referred to in respect of legal issues that could be raised, and clearly by the defence in relation to the matter. It seems to me that that of course is as a matter of fact correct, but what effect does it have on the jury. I think the indication, as a matter of law, when questions of admissibility or legal issues of any kind, apart from issues of admissibility, it is open to defence counsel, it is open to prosecution counsel, it is indeed open to the judge to raise issue in relation to the admissibility of evidence in the course of a criminal trial. I do intend to explain that to the jury and to leave it at that, and that's as far as I'm going on it. I'm not going to discharge the jury on that basis.
Insofar as it can be conveyed to a jury that legal issues arise, and insofar as that might be linked to, or said to be linked to categories of evidence that are not going to be opened, I didn't discern an explicit link between the two issues in the course of the opening. And it seems to me that the phrase “other categories”, insofar as it has been explained to me by prosecuting counsel, insofar as what wasn't said, is consistent with the view which I had formed that the reference to “other categories” was open to just a general proposition in relation to what normally one does as a matter of prudence in opening a case for the prosecution is not to give hostages to fortune by outlining statements of fact that might not be actually proven in the course of a criminal trial and/or matters that might be the subject of a legal ruling and it might be unwise to open and/or just choose not to open particular areas of evidence, because there may be a conflict in the evidence and it might not be of very great assistance in the course of an opening to go down that road at that stage. So there are any number of reasons why categories of evidence might not be opened to the jury and an opening to a jury in respect of fact might be very short, if not to say bald, in relation to the extent of the facts to be opened to the jury.
In my view this jury has not been wholly prejudiced against the accused in the manner which would be required to warrant its discharge or give...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Start Your 7-day Trial
-
Director of Public Prosecutions v Brady
...from public spaces is generally admissible in a criminal trial. (See People (DPP) v. Thompson [2024] IECA 22; People (DPP) v. Dunbar [2024] IECA 85; People (DPP) v. Anghel [2024] IECA 90; and People (DPP) v. Harrington [2024] IECA 205 People (DPP) v. Anghel provides a comprehensive summ......
-
The Director of Public Prosecutions -v- Ryan
...public spaces is generally admissible in a criminal trial. (See The People (DPP) v. Thompson [2024] IECA 22; The People (DPP) v. Dunbar [2024] IECA 85; The People (DPP) v. Anghel [2024] IECA 90 (“ Anghel”); The People (DPP) v. Harrington [2024] IECA 153 and The People (DPP) v. Brady [2024] ......
-
The Director of Public Prosecutions v Tynan & Fitzgerald
...on joint enterprise. Regarding Mr Fitzgerald’s grounds, the Court held that: (1) similar to the situation in People (DPP) v Dunbar [2024] IECA 85, the evidence was highly relevant, it had the potential to (and indeed did) advance the investigation, identify suspects and provide relevant adm......
-
The Director of Public Prosecutions v Z. R
...insofar as necessary and practicable. The appellant also relies on the recent decision of this court in People (DPP) v Philip Dunbar [2024] IECA 85. 32 . Counsel submits that there is a real risk of unfairness to the appellant by way of a lost opportunity through no fault of his own to acce......