Director of Public Prosecutions v WC
| Jurisdiction | Ireland |
| Court | Supreme Court |
| Judge | Mr Justice Peter Charleton |
| Judgment Date | 24 October 2024 |
| Neutral Citation | [2024] IESC 48 |
| Docket Number | Supreme Court appeal number: S:AP:IE:2023:000125 [2023] IECA 179 High Court record number: 2019/299JR [2022] IEHC 229 Dublin Circuit Criminal Court bill number: DUDP 40417 |
[2024] IESC 48
Dunne J
Charleton J
O'Malley J
Collins J
Donnelly J
Supreme Court appeal number: S:AP:IE:2023:000125
Court of Appeal record number: 2022/0134
High Court record number: 2019/299JR
Dublin Circuit Criminal Court bill number: DUDP 40417
An Chúirt Uachtarach
The Supreme Court
Judicial review – Disclosure – Prosecution – Appellant appealing against the refusal to grant judicial review – Whether the refusal of the complainant to make further statements had been proved by the appellant to constitute such an irremediable denial of justice that no ruling by the trial judge during the criminal process and no appropriate direction to the jury at trial could enable the prosecution of the appellant to be in due course of law
Facts: The appellant was accused of a series of historic allegations of sexual violence. The complainant gave extensive background information and documents. Asked by the appellant for yet more information, at a certain point, she declined further cooperation. The appellant commenced judicial review in the High Court seeking orders to halt his prosecution. The High Court stayed the prosecution: [2022] IEHC 229. The respondent, the Director of Public Prosecutions, appealed to the Court of Appeal, where the appeal was allowed: [2023] IECA 179. Leave to appeal was granted by the Supreme Court: [2023] IESCDET 134. In the determination and subsequent case management it was decided that the appeal should centre on the following issues: (i) Is it within the competence of criminal procedure for a notice for particulars, however formed, to be served on the prosecution, or the alleged victim of a crime, or to, in substance or in form, seek discovery from that source? (ii) Are there rights which inure to the alleged victim of sexual violence to be protected from enquiry into prior alleged incidents of that kind and if there is an interests of justice exception, does such require an application to the actual trial judge under s. 3 of the Criminal Law (Rape) Amendment Act 1981? (iii) What criteria are to be applied in such application at (ii)? (iv) Is there a privacy exception, or psychotherapeutic privilege, to an application for particulars or discovery, however formed, and when does this protect the alleged victim of sexual violence? (v) If there is any entitlement to obtain disclosure or particulars, however formed, form a complainant as to the details of any other alleged incidents of sexual violence, what criteria are to be applied in the assessment of whether it is necessary for the purposes of ensuring a fair trial that the defendant obtains such material? (vi) When may judicial review be granted instead of the trial judge ruling on applications as to the fairness of a criminal trial?
Held by the Court that it is the duty of the prosecution to produce to the defence whatever may assist in a realistic exploration of the accused’s guilt or innocence at trial. The Court held that the prosecution may not have access to everything of genuinely potential relevance; foreign agencies may be thought to hold records or, as in this case, the complainant may eventually come to the conclusion that enough is enough. The Court held that proper disclosure is part of the responsibility of the trial judge, which includes any judge making a preliminary ruling in aid of a fair trial. The Court held that such issues are not properly to be diverted through a pre-trial, or preliminary hearing, application for judicial review. The Court held that it may be appropriate to answer the issue posed in the determination issued by the Court in giving leave for a further appeal. The Court offered such observations as would assist the trial judge in the discovery application.
The Court dismissed the appeal against the refusal to grant judicial review.
Appeal dismissed.
Judgment of Mr Justice Peter Charleton delivered on Thursday 24 October 2024
Can judicial review in the High Court be used to prevent a criminal trial on the ground of supposedly inadequate disclosure of background to an allegation of sexual violence? Is this issue, of what and how much disclosure to order, the responsibility alone of the judge who hears that trial? How is disclosure, increasingly being sought as to private, intimate and historical records, including therapeutic notes, to be approached by trial judges?
These issues arise from a request for disclosure by WC, who is a man accused of a series of historic allegations of sexual violence. The complainant has already given extensive background information and documents. Asked by the accused for yet more information, at a certain point, she declined further cooperation. These circumstances require focus on how extensively, and intrusively, a court may require disclosure of the personal, medical and counselling records of those who assert themselves to be the victims of criminal offences. While those issues impact on many types of criminal trials, questions arise most especially in applications by accused persons to enquire into what a complainant, often under-age, has been noted to have said to others as to the commission of sexual violence.
Two considerations are central to what follows. Firstly, whether judicial review can lie on an accused applying to the High Court claiming that disclosure in a criminal case has been inadequate. Such an application is to stop a prosecution, thus completely removing the trial judge from control over the process of disclosure. On the basis of the analysis that follows, the control of disclosure, what is to be furnished to an accused and whether what has been disclosed suffices to enable a trial in due course of law, is a matter solely for the trial judge. It may also be noted that it is often the case that increased focus may falsely magnify the effect of a disclosure which is late. When disclosure is late, the effect of what is uncovered is not to unrealistically amplify the significance of what is newly revealed. Judges bear the same responsibility as during the trial, which is to adjudicate realistically whether what has been uncovered has had a real impact on the soundness of the trial process or on the safety of the conviction. Thus, secondly, it is necessary for this Court to offer general guidance on the proper approach to disclosure in criminal cases. As well as addressing this specific issue raised, this judgment necessarily should address relevance, any countervailing rights of a person complaining of a crime, and the limits on cross-examination.
The essential context here is a sexual violence allegation. Particular rules thus apply. Prior to the reforms introduced by the Criminal Law (Rape) Act 1981, those with experience attending courts will recall that sexual violence prosecutions were unrestricted as to public access. For the central witness, testifying would always be a particular ordeal as she, would have to speak in public alleging an intimate, but violent or coerced, experience. Previously, at common law, evidence of the complainant's sexual past was freely treated as relevant to the truth of an allegation and was thus treated as admissible. Hence, prior to the 1981 Act, enquiry by cross-examination on behalf of an accused about how a complainant had generally conducted herself in the past as to sexual relations not only with the accused but also with third parties was unrestricted. The only fetter on cross-examination was the imprecise requirement that questions for the accused should be put responsibly and should be on the accused's instructions or should reasonably arise from the circumstances alleged on the prosecution case. Such an ill-defined standard ostensibly enabled, prior to this legislative intervention, intimate relations with others to become the focus of a cross-examination. This extended even as to asking if the complainant had any sexual experience prior to an incident, and could involve traversing the entire of any real or asserted relationship within which that occurred. That legal context has changed and that is a key element of a disclosure application. It would be wrong to order disclosure or to stop a trial because disclosure had not been forthcoming as to evidence that could never be adduced at trial or in respect of which a trial judge would not allow a complainant to be asked in cross examination. Discussion at trial of prior sexual experience is now circumscribed by law.
Section 3(1) of the 1981 Act has limited both evidence concerning and questions asked of a complainant in a sexual violence trial. This provides that: “no question shall be asked in cross-examination at the trial, by or on behalf of any accused person at the trial, about any sexual experience of a complainant with a person other than that accused.” Leave could be given, under s 3(2)(b), in that regard, by the trial judge if “and only if, he is satisfied that it would be unfair to the accused person to refuse to allow the evidence to be adduced or the question” to be asked “that is to say, if he is satisfied that, on the assumption that if the evidence or question was not allowed the jury might reasonably be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the accused person is guilty, the effect of allowing the evidence or question might reasonably be that they would not be so satisfied.” That ruled out, save for good reason and with the leave of the judge, questions as to, and evidence about, the complainant's sexual history vis-à-vis other people than the accused.
By s 13 of the Criminal Law (Rape)(Amendment) Act 1990 the restriction on evidence and cross-examination was tightened so as to focus on the allegation itself and to exclude evidence of any prior sexual encounter between the accused and the complainant. Prior sexual acts with the accused could be...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Start Your 7-day Trial
-
The People (at the suit of the Director of Public Prosecutions) v M.S
...is nonetheless a factor. Importantly, the rights of victims (including complainants) must be considered at trial ( People (DPP) v WC [2024] IESC 48). This is especially relevant in so far as vulnerable witnesses, most especially child witnesses alleging sexual abuse, are cross-examined. The......
-
Smith v The Director of Public Prosecutions
...the right to a fair trial). 86 . This Court has recently addressed privacy issues and victims in two important judgments, namely WC v DPP [2024] IESC 48 (“ WC”) and The People (DPP) v AM [2025] IESC 16 (“ AM”). With respect to counselling material and echoing Charleton J. in WC, Collins J. ......
-
Director of Public Prosecutions v A.M
...by law, though such a power is conferred by Section 19A in relation to counselling records and in WC v Director of Public Prosecutions [2024] IESC 48 (“ WC”) this Court took the view that section 6 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2021, and in particular the provisions of section 6(8)(f), give......