Europe's Highest Court Rules On Registration Of CTM Licences

Author:Mr Peter Bolger
Profession:Mason Hayes & Curran
 
FREE EXCERPT

The Court of Justice of the European Union ("CJEU") has recently ruled on whether licensees of a Community Trade Mark ("CTM") (now known as a European Union trade mark or "EUTM") need to have registered the licence in the Register of Community trade marks (the "Register") in order to bring an action for infringement of the licenced trade mark.

In the case in question (Case c-163/15) the licensee had not registered its CTM licence in the Register. The infringing party sought to rely on Art 23(1) of the Council Regulation (EC) No 207/2009 of 26 February 2009 on the Community Trade Mark (the "Regulation") to prevent the licensee from taking action against him, on the basis that the licence had not been registered.

CJEU Analysis

The CJEU was asked to interpret the first sentence of Article 23(1) of the Regulation, which reads "Legal acts referred to in Articles 17, 19, and 22 concerning a Community trade mark shall have effects vis-à-vis third parties in all Member States only after entry in the Register."

Articles 17, 19, & 22 of the Regulation cover transfer of a CTM, the creation of rights in rem over a CTM and the grant of a licence respectively.

When read in isolation the first sentence of Article 23(1) appears to suggest that a licensee cannot enforce its rights against third party infringers if the licence is not registered. However the CJEU considered it in the context of other provisions in the Regulation.

Article 17 of the Regulation relates to the transfer of CTMs. Article 17(6) specifically provides that a transfer of a CTM cannot be invoked by the successor in title until such time as it has been entered on the Register. There is no similar provision in the Regulation in relation to CTM licences.

The CJEU are of the opinion that if it was intended that such a requirement exist in relation to CTM licences, then Article 22 of the Regulation which relates to licences would contain a...

To continue reading

REQUEST YOUR TRIAL