The Good Wife: Security For Loans And The Rights Of Spouses

Author:Mr Declan Black and Louis Mooney
Profession:Mason Hayes & Curran
 
FREE EXCERPT

In Goodbody Stockbrokers v Allied Irish Banks and Patterson1 Goodbody stockbrokers sought to resolve a situation where it was facing competing claims for a share portfolio account it held. On one hand, AIB had a letter of pledge from the account holder committing the account as security for a loan which was not performing, and which AIB was seeking to enforce. On the other hand, the account-holder's wife argued that the portfolio account was 50% beneficially owned by her, and so her portion or the whole account could not be lawfully liquidated to the bank's order and benefit. The Decision The account-holder, Mr Patterson, held a share portfolio account with the plaintiff stockbrokers for many years and did so before meeting and marrying Mrs Patterson. Mrs Patterson's evidence was that before marrying Mr Patterson, they agreed that they would jointly own the share portfolio account. She argued that when Mr Patterson purported to pledge this account to the bank, this was ineffective, either in whole or in part, as at least half the account belonged to, or was held in trust for, Mrs Patterson, and that her interest superseded any the bank may have. The bank argued that Mrs Patterson had never contributed to the account and so had no beneficial interest in it. Furthermore the bank took the charge over the account from Mr Patterson in good faith and without notice of any claim of Mrs Patterson. The bank also argued that Mrs Patterson waived her right to complain about the charge because an excessive amount of time (five years) had passed without...

To continue reading

REQUEST YOUR TRIAL