Ireland's Defamation Laws In The Spotlight

Author:Mr Michael Byrne

Independent Newspapers looks set to challenge Ireland's defamation laws after reportedly filing papers with the European Court of Human Rights.  The challenge concerns a €1.87 million damages award made against Independent Newspapers in 2009, the highest ever such award at that time, following its publication of a number of defamatory articles about the PR consultant, Monica Leech.

While the Supreme Court subsequently reduced the award on appeal to €1.25 million, the media group will nevertheless contend that Ireland's defamation law, in allowing for such a large award, is incompatible with the right to freedom of expression under the European Convention on Human Rights.  The "serious chilling effect" that the award has on freedom of expression is said by Independent Newspapers to be a consequence of inadequate domestic safeguards to mitigate against disproportionately large awards.

Independent Newspapers previously brought a similar case to the European Court of Human Rights after a substantial damages award was made against it in favour of the former government minister, Proinsias De Rossa.  On...

To continue reading