RGRE Grafton Ltd v Bewley's Cafe Grafton Street Ltd and Another
| Jurisdiction | Ireland |
| Court | Supreme Court |
| Judge | Mr. Justice Maurice Collins |
| Judgment Date | 18 February 2026 |
| Neutral Citation | [2026] IESC 10 |
| Docket Number | S:AP:IE:2024:000159 |
[2026] IESC 10
O' Donnell C.J.
Dunne J.
O' Malley J.
Woulfe J.
Collins J.
S:AP:IE:2024:000159
AN CHÚIRT UACHTARACH
THE SUPREME COURT
Property – Ownership – Tenant fixtures – Parties seeking ownership of six windows – Whether the windows were tenant fixtures
Facts: A dispute arose between the respondent, RGRE Grafton Ltd (the Landlord), and the appellant, Bewley’s Café Grafton Street Ltd (the Tenant), as to the ownership of six windows (the Four Orders and the Swan Yard windows) in Bewley’s Café on Grafton Street (the Premises). The High Court upheld the Landlord’s claim of ownership in relation to the Four Orders but held that the Tenant owned the Swan Yard windows ([2023] IEHC 25). Neither side accepted the High Court’s judgment and both sides appealed to the Court of Appeal, each asserting ownership of all six windows. The Court of Appeal, by a majority, allowed the Landlord’s appeal and disallowed the Tenant’s cross-appeal ([2024] IECA 199). The Supreme Court granted leave to appeal. The focus of the appeal was on the correctness or otherwise of the findings of the Court of Appeal (in part agreeing with and in part disagreeing with the findings of the High Court) that all six windows had, on their installation in 1928, become “part and parcel” of the Premises and thus the property of the Landlord. The arguments of the parties centred on factual and evidential issues, rather than on the principles governing the law of fixtures. The issues that came more and more to the fore as the appeal unfolded related to the limits of reliable judicial fact finding.
Held by Collins J that the High Court Judge correctly concluded that the Four Orders were “part and parcel” of the Premises and therefore the property of the Landlord. Collins J held that the High Court Judge erred in concluding that the Swan Yard windows were not “part and parcel” of the Premises and were instead tenant fixtures which the Tenant could remove pursuant to s. 17 of the Landlord and Tenant (Amendment) Act 1860. Collins J held that that conclusion relied on a “double fenestration” theory for which there was no adequate evidence and which was inconsistent with the weight of the available evidence. He held that the Court of Appeal was accordingly correct to set aside that finding. She held that it followed that the Swan Yard windows were equally “part and parcel” of the Premises and accordingly the property of the Landlord. In any event, she held that the Tenant failed to satisfy a “threshold condition” for its claim to ownership of the windows, namely that it had paid for, or undertaken the liability for, the windows. She noted that the Tenant accepted that it bore the burden of proof. She found that the evidence was in critical respects fragmentary and the fragments that were available were uncertain or ambiguous and the evidence was simply not adequate to permit the court to make a positive finding one way or the other. She found that the Tenant had therefore failed to discharge the burden of proof.
Collins J held that the Tenant’s appeal must fail and the order made by the Court of Appeal must be affirmed.
Appeal dismissed.
JUDGMENT of Mr. Justice Maurice Collins delivered on 18 February 2026
Harry Clarke (1889–1931) is widely regarded as Ireland's greatest stained glass artist. His stained glass windows adorn churches across Ireland, from Dublin to West Cork to Mayo and beyond, and his work is also to be found in many museums here, including the Hugh Lane Gallery, the National Museum and the Crawford Art Gallery, as well as in churches and museums beyond the boundaries of the State. Even so, his entry in the Dictionary of Irish Biography suggests that his “ most frequently viewed windows are probably the six he made for Bewley's café, Grafton St., Dublin (1927)”.
Bewley's Café on Grafton Street (or, to give its proper title, Bewley's Oriental Café) (in this judgment “ the Café” or “ the Premises”) takes its name from the Bewley family, a prominent Dublin Quaker family. Samuel Bewley is said to have been the first person to import tea directly from China to Ireland. 1 The family subsequently expanded into the coffee business and opened a number of Oriental Cafés in Dublin City Centre in the 1890s, none of which are now in business. From the 1890s on, the business was under the control of Ernest Bewley (Grandson of Samuel). In 1925–1926, Ernest assembled a site for a new flagship café on Grafton Street, intending that he would own the premises but that the café would be operated by a company, Bewley's Oriental Cafés Ltd (which was incorporated in April 1926), which would be granted a lease by him for that purpose. Ernest Bewley was chairman, director and shareholder of Bewley's Oriental Cafés Ltd and his dual role (as landlord and as principal of the tenant) is a factor contributing significantly to the many complexities and uncertainties surrounding the resolution of the issues arising in these proceedings and this appeal.
The windows with which the proceedings are concerned were commissioned in 1927 from Joshua Clarke & Sons, Harry Clarke's father's firm, in which Harry Clarke was responsible for stained glass commissions. Their cost was relatively modest (a total of £460 for all six) but they are now very valuable. The windows were designed specifically for the new Café. However, while the Café opened in November 1927, the windows were not installed until March/April 1928, a fact which is said to be significant. Since their installation, the windows have been in the Café almost without interruption (they were removed for safekeeping during the Second World War and were also removed for refurbishment in 1998) but the configuration and functioning of the windows has undergone significant alterations since their installation in 1928. The fact that the windows were capable of being removed – and have in fact been removed from time to time – is also said to be important.
The ownership of the six windows is the subject of these hard-fought proceedings. On one side of the dispute is RGRE Grafton Limited, which now holds the landlord's interest in the Premises (hereafter “ the Landlord”). On the other is Bewley's Café Grafton Street Limited (as Bewley's Oriental Cafés Limited is now called). It was granted a 21-year lease of the Premises in March 1928 (the term of which commenced on 1 April 1927) and a new 100-year lease was granted to it by Ernest Bewley's successors in title in 1949. In this judgment, Bewley's Café Grafton Street Ltd is referred to as “ the Tenant”). The Tenant has been in continuous occupation of the Premises since 1927 (though ownership of the Tenant changed in 1987).
In December 2020, the Tenant entered into an agreement with the other party to these proceedings, Bewley's Limited (its parent company) to transfer ownership of the windows (and certain other assets) to it and Bewley's Limited in turn agreed to grant a licence to the Tenant providing for the continued use of the windows in the Café. A dispute then arose between Landlord and Tenant as to the ownership of the windows and the Landlord challenged the validity of the purported transfer to Bewley's Limited, leading to the commencement of these proceedings. Bewley's Limited's claim to ownership of the windows is wholly dependent on the Tenant having been the owner as of the date of the impugned transfer in December 2020. It has no independent claim to the windows. In this judgment, references to “ the Tenant” should be read as including Bewley's Limited, unless otherwise stated.
The six windows at issue (and in referring to “ windows” I should acknowledge that the appropriateness of that term is contested by the Tenant; as we shall see, however, it is the
term consistently used by Harry Clarke himself and in any event it is the appropriate term in my view) comprise four windows known as the Four Orders (because they represent four of the orders of classical architecture) 2 and two windows referred to as the Swan Yard windows (because they originally set into window openings in the south-facing wall of the Café, overlooking a laneway to the rear of the Premises called Swan Yard).The Four Orders (which cost £280) were (and still are) set into window openings in the western wall of the Premises. Each is divided into four sashes and each sash is in turn divided into three panels, intended to be read vertically. Originally, each was fitted with a sophisticated brass “ hopper mechanism” which allowed the top three sashes to be opened by manipulating a brass rod running lengthways down one side of the windows (the bottom sash could be opened manually without any difficulty). Subsequently, the position of the hopper mechanism was altered so that it opened the bottom three sashes and at a later point the mechanism was removed entirely.
The Swan Yard windows (total cost £180) are different in design. They are divided into eight inward-opening sashes, each comprising two panels. They were also originally fitted with a hopper mechanism to control opening/closing. The precise location and arrangement of the Swan Yard windows at the time of their installation was the subject of significant dispute in the High Court. In any event, it is clear that one of the window openings overlooking Swan Yard was blocked up at some point between 1928 and 1986. Subsequently, as a result of work undertaken in 1987 to install a fire escape staircase in the south-western corner of the Premises, both Swan Yard windows were moved from the external wall to a new internal wall within the Café, where they are backlit so as to give the appearance of windows (the Four Orders are now also backlit and no longer serve to ventilate the...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Start Your 7-day Trial
-
Wild Ireland Defence CLG v an Coimisiún Pleanála and Ors [No. 2]
...of proof to establish all facts necessary for relief. As stated by Collins J. in RGRE Grafton Ltd v Bewley's Café Grafton Street Limited [2026] IESC 10, §83: “Discharging the burden of proof requires evidence of sufficient adequacy to enable a reliable assessment of probability.” As stated ......
-
Ballyboden Tidy Towns Company Ltd by Guarantee v an Coimisiún Pleanála
...of proof to establish all facts necessary for relief. As stated by Collins J. in RGRE Grafton Ltd v Bewley's Café Grafton Street Limited [2026] IESC 10, §83: “Discharging the burden of proof requires evidence of sufficient adequacy to enable a reliable assessment of probability.” As stated ......
-
Little Island Community Association CLG v an Coimisiún Pleanála and Ors
...of proof to establish all facts necessary for relief. As stated by Collins J. in RGRE Grafton Ltd v Bewley's Café Grafton Street Limited [2026] IESC 10, §83: “Discharging the burden of proof requires evidence of sufficient adequacy to enable a reliable assessment of probability.” As stated ......
-
Beatty v Beatty
...[2011] IEHC 269 per Charleton J. at para. 20). As Collins J. explained in RGRE Grafton Ltd. v. Bewley's Café Grafton Street Ltd. and anor [2026] IESC 10 at para. 82: ‘ Determining whether the party bearing the burden of proof of establishing proposition A, has discharged its burden may invo......