Flynn v Desmond


[2015] IECA 34


Peart J.

Hogan J

Mahon J.

Appeal No. 685/14
Flynn v Desmond
[Article 64 Transfer]
Laurence Flynn

- and -

Finbarr Desmond

685/2014 - Peart Hogan Mahon - Court of Appeal - 26/2/2015 - 2015 IECA 34

Personal Injury Claim – Costs – Appeal – Compensation – Practice and Procedures – Lack of Legal Representation – Medical Evidence – Work In jury – Agreements


Judgment of Mr. Justice Alan Mahon delivered on 26th February 2015


1. On 21 st November 2012 the High Court (Birmingham, J) made an order that these proceedings had been compromised by an agreement made between the Plaintiff and the Defendant on 12 th November 2009, wherein it was agreed that a sum of €5,000 (subsequently increased by agreement to €5,500) was to be paid to the Plaintiff in settlement of his personal injury claim. No order was made in relation to costs. The Plaintiff has appealed the High Court Order of 21 st November 2012 on a number of grounds.

The compromise of the High Court proceedings

2. The Plaintiff instituted proceedings in the High Court by plenary summons dated 17 th December 2007. He claimed damages for personal injury and loss arising from an incident which occurred in September or October 2004 when he sustained an injury to his right index finger while employed by the Defendant as a fisherman on a fishing vessel, "Bonne Chance", off the coast of Kinsale, Co. Cork.


3. On 12 th October 2009 the Defendant filed a Notice of Motion seeking an order that the Plaintiff's claim was statute barred by operation of s. 46(2) of the Civil Liability Act 1961, a provision which applies a two year limitation period to a claim for personal injury arising from a maritime accident.


4. At or about this time, a settlement meeting was arranged between the parties. The Plaintiff was not legally represented, nor indeed had he been at any time in the course of these proceedings. The settlement meeting took place on 12 th November 2009. The Defendant was represented by his solicitor, on the instructions of an insurance company. The opportunity to obtain legal advice was declined by the Plaintiff. At this meeting a settlement of the action was agreed, submitted to writing, and signed by the Plaintiff. The written agreement provided as follows:-


I, Laurence Flynn of 4 Upper Convent Road, Blackrock, in the County of Cork, being eighteen years and upwards, hereby do confirm that I have entered into a settlement agreement in the above entitled proceedings on the following terms:


1. Acknowledge full and final settlement in the entity of these proceedings in the sum of €5,000 to include general damages, special damages and any outlays incurred.


2. I hereby undertake as a term of settlement that I will file and lodge, in the Central Office of the Four Courts, and serve on Conways Solicitors, 35 South Terrace, Cork, a Notice of Discontinuance within fourteen days of the receipt of the cheque.


3. I hereby enter into this settlement agreement in full knowledge that no admission of liability has been made.


4. I hereby confirm that I will agree to this agreement being entered into in the strictest terms of confidentiality and that I will not discuss this claim and its subsequent settlement with anyone.


I sign this agreement in the full knowledge and understanding that I have been invited to consult with an independent legal advisor prior to signing this document but I have waived this right and I am happy to do so with the full knowledge as to the consequence and import of this agreement.


Signed: Laurence Flynn


Dated the 12 th November 2009


5. On 15 th November 2009, some three days after the agreement, the Plaintiff wrote to, and emailed, the Defendant's solicitor informing him that he was unhappy with the settlement because the agreed compensation figure represented a minor injury, whereas his injury was serious and was likely to get worse with the passage of time. It would appear that in the weeks that followed, the Plaintiff reconsidered his position again and, undoubtedly prompted by a commitment on the part of the Defendant to pay an additional €500 making the total compensation figure €5,500, the Plaintiff confirmed in writing the settlement of the action in a communication with the Defendant's solicitor on 23 rd December 2009. A...

To continue reading