Friends of the Environment CLG v The Government of Ireland
Jurisdiction | Ireland |
Judge | Clarke C.J.,Irvine J.,Baker J. |
Judgment Date | 13 February 2020 |
Neutral Citation | [2020] IESCDET 13 |
Date | 13 February 2020 |
Court | Supreme Court |
Docket Number | S:AP:IE:2019:000205 |
AND
[2020] IESCDET 13
Clarke C.J.
Irvine J.
Baker J.
S:AP:IE:2019:000205
2017 No. 793 JR
THE SUPREME COURT
DETERMINATION
RESULT: The Court grants leave to the Applicant to appeal to this Court directly from the High Court.
REASONS GIVEN:
ORDER SOUGHT TO BE APPEALED
COURT: High Court |
DATE OF JUDGMENT OR RULING: 19th September, 2019 |
DATE OF ORDER: 22nd October, 2019 |
DATE OF PERFECTION OF ORDER: 25th October, 2019 |
The general principles applied by this Court in determining whether to grant leave to appeal from a decision of the High Court or of the Court of Appeal have been considered in a number of determinations and are fully addressed in both a determination issued by a panel consisting of all of the members of this Court in B. S. v. Director of Public Prosecutions [2017] IESCDET 134 and in a unanimous judgment of a full Court delivered by O'Donnell J. in Price Waterhouse Coopers (A Firm) v. Quinn Insurance Ltd. (Under Administration) [2017] IESC 73, [2017] 3 IR 812.
In addition, because this is an application for leave to appeal directly from the High Court, it is necessary that it be established that there are “exceptional circumstances” warranting a direct appeal to this Court. The Supreme Court held in Mackeral v. O'Donoghue [2015] IESCDET 27 that it would generally allow a leapfrog appeal only where the exceptional factor or factors identified make it probable both that:
(a) the case will come to the Supreme Court in any event, and;
(b) the clarification of the legal issues raised would be unlikely to significantly benefit from an intermediate appeal to the Court of Appeal.
Furthermore, the application for leave filed and the respondents' notice are published along with this determination (subject only to any redaction required by law) and it is therefore unnecessary to set out the position of the parties.
Whilst the respondents do not oppose the granting of leave, this Court must itself be satisfied that the constitutional threshold has been met.
Any ruling in a determination concerns whether the facts and legal issues meet the constitutional...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Friends of the Irish Environment v The Government of Ireland
...2.1 By determination dated 13 th February 2020 ( Friends of the Environment CLG v. The Government of Ireland & The Attorney General [2020] IESCDET 13) this Court granted FIE leave to appeal the decision of the High Court for the following reasons:- “8. The applicant and the respondents acce......
-
Whither Constitutional Environmental (Rights) Protection In Ireland After ?Climate Case Ireland'?
...of Ireland [2019] IEHC 747 [132]. 14 ibid [112]. 15 ibid [97]. 16 ibid [145]. 17 ibid [121]. 18 ibid [133]. 19 [2017] IEHC 695. 20 [2020] IESCDET 13. 21 Friends of the Irish Environment v The Government of Ireland [2020] IESC 49 [6.27]. [2021] Irish Judicial Studies Journal Vol 5(2) 29 IRIS......