Miranda v Rosas Construtores

• Jurisdiction: Ireland
• Judge: Clarke C.J.,McKechnie J.,MacMenamin J.
• Judgment Date: 09 April 2020
• Neutral Citation: [2020] IESCDET 51
• Date: 09 April 2020
• Court: Supreme Court
• Docket Number: Supreme Court record no: S:AP:IE:2020:000013 High Court record no: 2012 No. 9537 P, 2012 No. 9538 P, 2012 No. 9535 P, 2013 No. 12219 P, 2014 No. 9212 P, 2014 No. 2244 P, 2014 No. 3319 P

BETWEEN

CARLOS MANUEL MIRANDA ALFREDO MARTINS RODRIGUES FERNANDES VICTOR MANUEL MARQUES DE OLIVEIRA MARIA PIEDOSA RIBEIRO CARDOSA GASTALHO FRANCISCO PEREIRA MARTINS JOSE MARIA COELHO BARBOSA CARLOS JOSE LONGA

PLAINTIFFS

AND

ROSAS CONSTRUTORES S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

CONSTRUCOES GABRIEL AS COUTO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

AND

EMPRESA DECONSTRUCOES AMANDIO CARVALHO S.A. T/A RAC

CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

DEFENDANTS

BETWEEN

ARMANDO AGOSTINHO ALVES DA SILVA ALVARO ABILIO QUEIROS COELHO HELDER FIGUEIREDO MARIO AUGUSTO RAMALHO GASTALHO SAMUEL FILIPE DA SILVA OLIVERIA JOSE ANTONIO FONSECA RIBEIRO ALBERTO BESSA LEITE LUIS RODRIGUES DIAS MOURATO JOSE DUARTE MAGALHAES JOSE MARIA MARTINS VELOSO

PLAINTIFFS

AND

ROSAS CONSTRUTORES S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

CONSTRUCOES GABRIEL AS COUTO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

AND

EMPRESA DECONSTRUCOES AMANDIO CARVALHO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

DEFENDANTS

BETWEEN

JOSE MONTEIRO DA SILVA NUNO PEDRO GONCALVES LOPES DAVID SARAIVA MATIAS ANTONIO BARBOSA MOREIRA JOSE FRANCISCO OLIVIERA DA SILVA JORGE DA SILVA LUIS JOSE TEXEIRA GONCALVES ANTONIO JORGE OLIVEIRA BESSA FRANCISCO DA COSTA FERRIERA JOSE LUIS FREITAS LIMA

PLAINTIFFS

AND

ROSAS CONSTRUTORES S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

CONSTRUCOES GABRIEL AS COUTO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

AND

EMPRESA DECONSTRUCOES AMANDIO CARVALHO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

DEFENDANTS

BETWEEN

CARLOS MANUEL OLIVEIRA MATOS CARLOS ALBERTO OLIVEIRA MATOS RUI MIGUEL DOS REIS SERPA CORTE REAL MANUEL JOAQUIM ALVES MACHADO FERREIRA HELDER FILIPE BARBOSA GONCALVES JORGE ALEXANDRE UMBELINO AGOSTINHO DE SILVA SAMPAIO JOSE ALFREDO QUINTANS MAGALHAES VICTOR MANUEL CARDOSA ALMEIDA

PLAINTIFFS

AND

ROSAS CONSTRUTORES S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

CONSTRUCOES GABRIEL AS COUTO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

AND

EMPRESA DECONSTRUCOES AMANDIO CARVALHO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

DEFENDANTS

BETWEEN

ANTONIO GERMANO ALVES GUEDES MONTEIRO ANTONIO GUEDES MONTEIRO ARTUR JOAO ALONSO MOREIRA

PLAINTIFFS

AND

ROSAS CONSTRUTORES S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

CONSTRUCOES GABRIEL AS COUTO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

AND

EMPRESA DECONSTRUCOES AMANDIO CARVALHO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

DEFENDANTS

BETWEEN

JOSE MANUEL RIBEIRO ALMEIDA CARLOS MANUEL MONTEIRO, ALBERTO DA CRUZ COEHLO MANUEL ALBERTO PEREIRA DUARTE JOAO PAULO RODRIGUES LEMOS SERGIO ANTONIO CARVALHO JOAO FILIPE OLIVEIRA GONCALVES VITOR MANUEL FORMOSO PEREIRA

PLAINTIFFS

AND

ROSAS CONSTRUTORES S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

CONSTRUCOES GABRIEL AS COUTO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

AND

EMPRESA DECONSTRUCOES AMANDIO CARVALHO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

DEFENDANTS

BETWEEN

RAMIRO ABRANTES DO CARMOS MANUEL SEBATIAO BRAS DE OLIVEIRA JOSE FERNANDO MAGALHAES DA SILVA

PLAINTIFFS

AND

ROSAS CONSTRUTORES S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

CONSTRUCOES GABRIEL AS COUTO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

AND

EMPRESA DECONSTRUCOES AMANDIO CARVALHO S.A. T/A RAC CONTRACTORS AND/OR RAC EIRE PARTNERSHIP

DEFENDANTS

[2020] IESCDET 51

Clarke C.J.

McKechnie J.

MacMenamin J.

Supreme Court record no: S:AP:IE:2020:000013

Court of Appeal record no: A:AP:IE:201:000163, A:AP:IE:201:000164, A:AP:IE:201:000165, A:AP:IE:201:000166, A:AP:IE:201:000167, A:AP:IE:201:000168, A:AP:IE:201:000169

High Court record no: 2012 No. 9537 P, 2012 No. 9538 P, 2012 No. 9535 P, 2013 No. 12219 P, 2014 No. 9212 P, 2014 No. 2244 P, 2014 No. 3319 P

THE SUPREME COURT

DETERMINATION

APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL TO WHICH ARTICLE 34.5.3° OF THE CONSTITUTION APPLIES

RESULT: The Court does not grant leave to the Defendant/Applicants to appeal to this Court from the Court of...